A frequent question I am often asked by my wife when returning from a trip is “Did you get any good pictures?” My frequent answer – “Maybe…” Often my answer comes just from thinking about the things I may have witnessed, but whether I have any good photographs depends on when and how I develop them. I have taken favor to using the term “develop” as opposed to “processing (or post-processing).” In most cases because I think it more accurately describes the creative process (ahem! 🙂 ) I am going through post-capture. Being an original film guy, it reflects back into that era as well. I have used them interchangeably in the past, wrongly thinking of them as synonyms. I am more disciplined in their use now.
This particular focus on a single word isn’t meant to be coy about the steps I go through in completing any particular photograph, but to communicate how I truly believe many, not all, photographs aren’t finished until they are developed. I have received some confused looks when answering people that I haven’t developed my pictures yet (when they know they are all digital). Much of the non-photographer public considers the camera as the final step. I even get bothered a little by the comment “Nice capture” from other photographers because maybe I was just there as the trigger man. I know it isn’t meant that way, but it is a particular aspect of language that doesn’t consider creativity and vision beyond the algorithms and pixels on the sensor.
Using the word “process” implies that you need to go through a set of predefined steps to reach a particular objective. However, more often than not, that objective may not be clear for me, nor are the steps to get there. My creative process could be defined as a combination of capture + developing. That basically remains the same. Using “processing” to define the later step falls short. A definition of the word develop fits appropriately: grow or cause to grow and become more mature, advanced, or elaborate. That maturity may come over years, maybe over days, maybe over an hour. It is really hard to nail down and varies photo to photo for me.
A case in point are the leaf photographs in this post. I actually took 2 different approaches to my post-capture activity on them. The first approach I could probably call processing. I went through standard tweaks on contrast, clarity, etc that don’t vary much image to image. The end result didn’t feel complete to me, I wanted something more from them. So I started over from scratch and started playing around with layers, blending them, luminosity masks, and some tonal filters with no real objective in mind. I just wanted something that looked interesting to me. During this play time, I started developing a unique look that I became quite enamored with. It became as big a part of the final look than the actual capture itself.
While this may seem pedantic to some, it is a small detail of language in describing our work that I believe is important. If you find yourself just going through the motions and processing your work, maybe it is time to go off trail a little bit and see what develops. 😉








Excellent post Mark. I used to let people use any words they wanted about my work at shows, now I try to challenge their vocabulary because I think they often have a misconception about the “process” of making a photograph. Words do matter, especially when someone uses one and I don’t know what they mean by it. I do believe that “develop” is still the right term and often assert that film did way too much of the work for me before. My customers are often surprised that I tell them digital image making is much more difficult than with film, I am now totally responsible for every decision and so if an image fails or succeeds, its totally on me.
Hey Paul, thanks for your thoughts on this. It’s true that film did take a rather large part of the creative choices in creating a look, though film choice itself was part of the creative decision of the photographer. Look at all the “film type” digital effects we have today to mimic the historical choice of what to load the camera with. We are freed now in that the look doesn’t have to be applied to every shot on the roll.
You couldn’t be more right on the words we choose. While some may consider it a matter of semantics, it does have some effect on how viewers interpret what we are showing them (if not educating).
You remind me now that it took me some time to get myself out of the habit of “seeing” like Fujichrome Velvia. I had learned to see and think of the world so much in those colors and contrast range that I was developing my work toward that end. We are free now to see the world through our own eyes as we should as artists.
The final answer for the wives question in the case of these leaves was most definitely…”Yes I did get some good photos.” Well developed! 😉
Thanks Brooks! (All of these weren’t photographed the same day, but hey, semantics… 🙂 )
Very well put Mark. I like the idea of “develop” vs “process” and even your sentiments on “nice capture”. Though I am not sure how else to refer to the “capture”. I have never liked a photograph to be referred to as “shot”. Hmm, more questions. I seem to go through the same exploration with many if not all images myself. Many times the initial capture of an image means very little. The experience always out ways the “capture”. What will happen with that initial capture is completely unknown at that time. Actually many times I do feel like I was only the trigger man. Even though any who understand what goes into a “worthy capture” is much more than simply pulling the trigger.
I have always enjoyed the processing, which I may now start referring to as developing due to your well put insight. I feel much more creative in the developing stage. But one feeds the other and they fit together to form what I always hope will be a final acceptable result. Acceptable or not they both feed needs that are hard to nourish any other way.
Glad you found some insight here Brad. I never liked the term “shot” either unless it is said with an Australian accent in terms of getting “the shot!!!” 🙂
Sometimes “developing” is a matter of working the image until the print or the monitor shows what I previsualized or saw in the viewfinder.
There may not be much work in some cases, but in others it can be a journey. Lately the journey for me has been getting colors right – either coping with the limitations of the print color gamut for a paper, or the sRGB color space for monitor display. Or adjusting contrast, reducing or increasing it.
And then sometimes developing involves taking an image to a place I didn’t previsualize – such as an unanticipated B&W conversion that makes an image come alive. As for terms, I’m agnostic about whether the correct term is develop or process. Sometimes it’s mechanical, sometimes not.
Very well put, Mark. I’d never actually given it much thought; however, you do make a great point about the difference between processing, a number of steps completed in order, for example, and development, a natural growth, if you will. I much prefer to develop pictures, perhaps over time or in multiple ways. I don’t think that there is one fixed outcome for a photo. Immediately my mind goes to software process vs. software development 🙂
As to how to answer that question: Did you get any good pictures, I’m afraid that I am unoriginal, using the same response as you: I hope so, possibly, or maybe, or the ever ambiguous, we will see. 🙂 Because, in truth, I may have some that I thought were pretty good at the time, but end up being not quite as “good” as I thought when they hit the big screen. Yet, there are others that I thought nothing about but develop into pictures that I really like, with the right development … which may come months, years later. It all depends on my mood and how far I’m willing to experiment with a photo.
The photos that you show here, as well as have shown here, are shall we say, well developed! 🙂
I’ve experienced much the same thing Paul, those images that just don’t have the magic in post that I imagined they would in the field. Then later on one you happen to stumble upon when in the right mood turns into something unexpected. I just wish my forsight was able to tell earlier in the field.
I’ve spent a lot of time in particular spots where I think I may have done better by moving on. It’s always balancing game.
Thanks for your thoughts here.
You’ve initiated a great discussion, Mark. Your back and forth with Cedric Canard is especially rich.
Words are important but so is the image, or photo or picture. 🙂 And, I’m not sure what words to use in my comments and will they be received as intended? One reason I read others blogs is because of the bits and pieces I receive from the posting. Thanks for sharing this from your post, “go off trail a little bit and see what develops.” By the way, these are Awesome images! So, to answer your wife, yes!
Indeed Monte, the only way to find out is to throw those comments out there and see if you get a reaction. Thanks sir!
It’s interesting how our semantics vary, Mark. Sometimes we give different meanings to the same word, and sometimes we use different words to describe the same activity. I have always used ‘process’ to describe what you refer to as ‘develop.’ But I remember always having my film ‘processed’ by a lab because I didn’t ‘develop’ it myself. Strange, isn’t it?
Cedric’s characterization of the differences between the two words mentions ‘vision,’ but I tend to see vision as what determines the outcome. We all use similar tools, but we achieve different results depending on how we use those tools to realize our vision. Interesting discussion!
I often viewed my slide film as being processed because E6 is pretty much standard thing. It was more of a mechanical step than a creative one.
For those that did their own, perhaps they did tweak things along the way? For certain those that ended up making prints in a darkroom developed them in a manner they felt best fit their vision.
Great post Mark. Like you I find the correct usage of words to be important. Words can be so rich in meaning and yet so ambiguous at the same time. However it is precisely for that reason that choosing the right words is important even if it’s no guarantee that the correct message will be conveyed. In any case I agree with your differentiation between processing and developing. It’s an excellent one I had not thought of but I will say that “developing”, with regards to photography, is the most perfect way of describing what is essentially the making of a vision. That’s the difference is it not? Post-processing is the application of presets, filters etc. to enhance a photo whereas developing is bringing out the vision from the photo.
I have often argued that artful photographs are made not taken or in other words, a photographer takes photos and an artist makes them. Which I think fits in with your idea of developing a photo versus processing.
Interestingly I have used the words “nice capture” or “beautiful capture” to describe some photos. Perhaps I have said this to some of yours. Perhaps I do this out of laziness or perhaps I do this when words fail; however when I say “nice capture” I always mean it in terms of capturing a vision not simply pressing a shutter button.
So in this instance if I was to say that your three photos are nice captures I would be saying: Your photos are beautifully captured visions of fall. You have developed photo of leaves into visions of decay, decline and a departed season. The subdued hues are an echo of golden summer sunsets and invoke an earthy aesthesis heralding the coming of winter which will in turn herald spring. That’s what I would be meaning.
By the way, your photos are really nice captures.
Haha, I wasn’t specifically thinking of you Cedric with that capture remark, but if you insist – I can be irked by them as well. 😉 kidding of course!!
Therein lies the nuance of language again. “Capture” can encompass from the simple mechanical act to a portrayal of a complete vision. A camera trap can get a good capture I suppose, and a painter can capture the essence of a landscape. Each has a possible chasm between them on the contribution of the artist.
The eloquent phrasing you made about the leaves here (thanks btw) is difficult to expect from a lot of people these days. I wonder if our rush to ~process~ so much information, viewing photos for only seconds is a contributor for shorter, summarized commentary. I am guilty myself then.
Quite right Mark, it is true that a vision can be captured/developed at the moment of firing the shutter. Henri Cartier-Bresson is a good example of someone who achieved this. And then there are those images that take much deliberation to develop such as Adams’ Moonrise shot which went through much development work in the darkroom and many versions before he settled on the one we all know.
As for the lack of appreciation, I do not think that the “rush to ~process~ so much information” is the culprit here, nor the shortened attention spans. I would propose that technology itself might have more to do with it. Modern cameras including those in phones have made it too easy for just about anyone to create something that mimics the work of past and existing master photographers.
When Jamie Beck and Kevin Burg first showed their cinemagraphs, the technique was not something any amateur could go an create at the press of a button but now I can go and make one in around 10 seconds or less using my phone.
As a more humble example, I remember going to great lengths to give images a painterly look by projecting slide-film (transparencies) onto textured panes of glass; now I can achieve the same effect with a digital photograph at the push of a button. Under such circumstances it becomes difficult to expect people to fully appreciate works that took vision and time to create. The ease with which things can be done these days seems to have removed appreciation for the labour-of-love concept in the human psyche. Just a thought.
Well modern cameras still don’t have that composition button. 🙂
Cameras have been good as far as exposure metering and focusing for decades now, but another thing technology has done is give us exposure to many more photographers via the Internet. Before then, it was just books and galleries right?
But with cameras being good, many artists do try to distinguish themselves in the latter part of developing, I am thinking Bagshaw or Adamus as examples.
Actually Mark, my camera does have a composition button which works pretty well unless the best composition is the one that breaks the rules; so there’s still that which is left up to skill 🙂
Exposure to other photographers has certainly helped raise the abilities of many people. People know what they like even if they can’t articulate why and after a while they will subconsciously imitate what they’ve seen other’s do in terms of composition and subject matter. That in itself is not a bad thing.
And yes, I totally agree that artists will always go beyond what technology can offer. Artists will stretch whatever is available to them in new and wondrous ways. Somehow I don’t see that ever changing. And to be frank, the number of people who can appreciate their efforts probably hasn’t changed over time. Even before all this modern technology, the number of people who appreciated the efforts of artists were probably no more than they are today.
well what a fancy camera you must have! 🙂 I agree with you on the understanding of artists, but as you stated, it is also a big thing to be able to articulate what you like about something. I struggle with that myself at times.
Like you and Howard, I also get asked about the results of a shoot. Most often I give the same answer…maybe or we’ll see…although I generally have a feel for the success or failure ahead of time. Occasionally an image comes out of the box ready to go, but most often processing or development is called for and I don’t think one truly expresses the feelings and emotions experienced in making an image without some after the fact work. A machine has no soul, despite what Kidder’s title may imply, and the soul or sensitivity of a person is requited to make art.
I certainly have many images that are fine straight out of camera, maybe just minor tweaks because they are Raw files. That just means that I was satisfied they were complete at that point.
That makes that question we get have a disclaimer on it, because those are mixed with others that do require more development work. 🙂
Funny, my wife asks me the same thing when I come back from photographing!
I view the ‘developing’ of the image as you so aptly put it as a process of exploration and discovery. So I find it a little disconcerting that some folks feel that just bringing an image into a plug in and choosing a filter button or applying a preset yields a finished piece of artwork. Different for the sake of being different doesn’t make it necessarily good. There, I have vented lol!
Your images here have that feel of exploration and discovery and the feel of having traveled down a road that they were meant to go on. That they ended as a finished product most appropriate for what they were to start with. Not sure if that makes any sense …..,
I know I feel more satisfaction in a final image if I made it there without a one click result. Not that presets are a bad thing, they can be a great idea generator or starting point. But if everyone just used the same preset, there wouldn’t be a lot of creativity to take in and experience.
Thanks for your thoughts here Howard.